For many steak lovers, achieving the perfect medium-rare steak is the holy grail of cooking. Medium rare steaks are often considered the most flavorful and tender because they retain the ideal balance between a juicy interior and a crispy exterior. But how do you know if your steak is cooked to perfection without using a thermometer?
While a meat thermometer is the most reliable way to check the doneness of steak, not everyone has one on hand—or prefers not to use it. Luckily, there are several tried-and-true methods to determine whether your steak is medium rare, using only your senses: touch, sight, and even sound. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the different ways you can assess your steak’s doneness without a thermometer, so you can confidently cook your next steak to the ideal medium-rare temperature.
What is Medium Rare Steak?
Before you can know if your steak temp medium rare, it helps to understand what this doneness level looks like. A medium-rare steak is characterized by:
- Internal temperature: Typically between 130°F and 135°F (54°C to 57°C).
- Appearance: The steak should have a warm red center with a slightly pink outer layer.
- Texture: A medium-rare steak will be tender, juicy, and offer some resistance when pressed.
- Juices: The steak should release a small amount of red, pink juice when cut or pressed, indicating that it hasn’t overcooked.
In contrast to steaks cooked to rarer or more well-done levels, a medium-rare steak offers a balance between the tenderness and flavor that many people seek in their ideal steak.
Signs of a Medium Rare Steak
When cooking a steak to medium rare without a thermometer, you’ll need to rely on a combination of techniques. Here are the main signs you should look for to determine if your steak is medium rare.
3.1. The Touch Test
One of the most reliable ways to check the doneness of a steak without a thermometer is the “touch test.” This method involves using your fingers to assess the firmness of the steak. The idea is to compare the feel of the steak to the fleshy part of your hand under different conditions.
To perform the touch test:
- For Medium Rare: Touch the fleshy part of your palm just below the thumb. When relaxed, this area should feel soft but with a slight firmness. Gently press your steak and compare the feel. A medium-rare steak should have the same softness and slight resistance. It should not feel mushy (which would indicate rare) or too firm (which would suggest medium well to well-done).
- For Reference:
- Rare: Soft and squishy, like the area below your thumb when you touch it with your relaxed hand.
- Medium: Slightly firmer, like the base of your thumb when you press it with your other hand.
- Well-Done: Very firm, like the area at the base of your thumb when you touch it and press hard.
This touch test works best if you become familiar with how your steak reacts at different stages of cooking. You can practice by cooking steaks to different doneness levels and using the touch test as a guide.
3.2. Visual Cues
Another way to gauge if your steak is medium rare is by examining its appearance. Here are some visual indicators that the steak is medium rare:
- Color: A medium-rare steak will have a warm, reddish-pink center. The exterior will have a nice browned, caramelized crust from the searing process. If the steak appears mostly red or very pink throughout, it’s likely closer to rare. If it’s turning brown or grayish in the middle, it has probably cooked past medium rare.
- Surface Texture: A well-seared crust will typically form on a medium-rare steak. The steak should have a firm exterior with grill marks or a browned surface, while the inside remains juicy and slightly pink.
For steaks cooked in the oven or via methods like reverse searing, the visual cues may be subtler but still noticeable when you cut into the steak.
3.3. Juice and Color of the Steak
When you cut into a medium-rare steak, the juices should be red or slightly pink, and the meat should still be tender and moist. If the steak is dry and the juices are clear, the steak has likely been cooked past medium rare. The juices of a medium-rare steak should not be running or watery but should have a slight reddish tint that indicates a proper medium-rare temperature.
Be cautious when you press the steak with a fork or tongs to check for juice—it’s important not to puncture the steak too many times, as this can release the juices and affect the final texture.
The Importance of Resting Steak
After you finish cooking your steak, it’s essential to let it rest for a few minutes before slicing into it. Resting allows the juices to redistribute throughout the meat, resulting in a more flavorful and juicy steak. For a medium-rare steak, let it rest for about 5 to 10 minutes.
During this resting period, the internal temperature of the steak may rise slightly (around 5°F), which is important to keep in mind when determining doneness. So, if you remove the steak from the heat when it’s just below 135°F, it will continue cooking while resting and reach that ideal temperature.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
When trying to achieve the perfect medium-rare steak without a thermometer, it’s easy to make a few common mistakes:
- Overcooking: If you rely solely on the visual cues or touch test, it’s easy to mistake a medium-rare steak for medium or even well-done. Practice is key to getting the timing right.
- Not Resting: Cutting into the steak immediately after cooking can cause the juices to escape, leading to a dry steak. Always let your steak rest.
- Pressing Too Hard: When performing the touch test, don’t press too hard on the steak. You’re looking for slight firmness, not a deep indentation.
- Not Using High Heat: For the best medium-rare steak, ensure that you sear the outside on high heat to lock in juices before finishing the steak to your desired doneness.
Tips for Perfectly Cooked Medium Rare Steak
Here are some helpful tips to make sure you get a perfectly cooked medium-rare steak every time:
- Choose the Right Cut: Some cuts are easier to cook to medium rare than others. Tender cuts like filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip are perfect for medium rare.
- Preheat Your Pan or Grill: Whether you’re cooking on a grill or stovetop, make sure your cooking surface is preheated to a high temperature before you add the steak. This ensures a good sear on the outside while keeping the inside tender and juicy.
- Don’t Flip Too Often: Let the steak cook on one side until it forms a nice crust, and then flip it over. Frequent flipping can prevent proper searing.
- Use the Right Tools: Tongs or a spatula are better for flipping and handling steaks than a fork, which can pierce the meat and release juices.
- Know Your Timing: Cook your steak for 3 to 5 minutes on each side for a 1-inch thick cut. Adjust based on thickness and personal preference.
We are a team with a huge appetite and a love for the Olive Garden. We believe that eating out can be informative, cost-friendly, and, most importantly, fun. Italians live their food, which is the spirit of the Olive Garden Menu price. Thus, we need to start this site to serve you current menu prices, special offers, and restaurant news.
Conclusion
Knowing if your steak is medium rare without a thermometer is absolutely possible once you understand the visual and tactile cues that indicate doneness. The touch test, visual inspection, and attention to the color and juiciness of the steak will help you achieve the perfect medium-rare steak every time. With a bit of practice, you’ll no longer have to rely on a thermometer, and you’ll be able to confidently serve up delicious, tender steaks that are perfectly cooked to medium rare.
Keep in mind that every steak is different, and factors like thickness, type of cut, and cooking method will affect the cooking time. So experiment, use your senses, and trust your instincts—before long, cooking the perfect medium-rare steak will feel like second nature!
